Proposals
for ‘precision education’ based on genomic and neural data about
students reproduce controversies around genetic discrimination,
cognitive enhancement, and biological reductionism in data-intensive
science and technology.
Human
bodies have become highly valuable informational resources in
data-intensive forms of postgenomics and neuroscientific research,
application, and commodification. Biodata related to education is
increasingly available, as huge biobanks of genomic data and new
neurotechnologies have developed, leading to a raft of multidisciplinary
initiatives focused on the ideal of ‘precision learning’. While
education is already subject to many ‘big data’ programs—such as
learning analytics—precision learning represents a shift to ‘intimate
data’ and the mining and analysis of biodata from the human body.
This
presentation will open up precision learning to social scientific
examination. Drawing on recent science and technology studies of
data-centred postgenomics, bioinformatics and neuroscience, as well as
on critical data studies and biosocial conceptualisations, precision
education initiatives will be approached as the hybrid product of three
interpenetrating ‘codes’: biological codes pertaining to fleshy bodies,
computer codes that instruct bioinformatic technologies, and social
codes related to governing the expected or desired conduct of students.
Controversy:
Proposals for ‘precision education’ based on genomic and neural data
about students reproduce controversies around genetic discrimination,
cognitive enhancement, and biological reductionism in data-intensive
science and technology.